Science Forums 2

[Moontanman]

In Newtons proof that all mass can be considered to be located at an orbs center, he showed that regardless of distribution of mass in the shells the gravitational attraction on the orbs surfice would be equal to considering all mass to be located at its center. Hence moving mass from the core to the mantle doesn't change the outcome.

That has nothing what so ever to do with what I am saying, if you are going to try and address my arguments please do not change them to suit you.

I guess I will have to inform Dr. Silvera that his diamond anvil results must be thrown out because Moontanman says you cannot get rid if the heat generated by pressure through convection, conduction or radiation. Once the heat is gone, you cannot have pressure create more unless the pressure changes.

You can inform him of anything you please, that is not what I said and I don't give a rats ass about diamond anvils in labs. In the real world to make metallic hydrogen you have to have pressure, enough pressure to turn hydrogen into a metal. to do this you need thousands of miles of hydrogen gas because heavier elements will displace the hydrogen rather than compress it. You cannot cover hydrogen gas up with iron to press it into metallic hydrogen in the real world. In the real world iron goes to the center, hydrogen floats on top. Now what real world process can cause iron to float on top of hydrogen gas?