Go Back   Science Forums > Physical Sciences Forums > Astronomy and Cosmology
Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 09-10-2004   #1 (permalink)
geeteenodubya's Avatar
Curious


 
geeteenodubya is an unknown quantity at this point
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Is space something or nothing?

One can derive a solution for the properties of "empty space," but does it make sense? Is there any reason to assume a geometry must exist -- that there cannot be two entirely unrelated things or worlds? If there is no pre-existing relationship defined by some geometry, then two things must either be adjacent or overlapping throughout their existence if they are to interact causally at any point. It seems to me that quantum mechanics has shown that the contents of our spacetime might define our spacetime itself, not just its shape and metric.
Old 09-10-2004   #2 (permalink)
Tormod's Avatar
Hypographer

Administrator
Senior Editor
Editor
Dev Team Member

Location:
Oslo, Norway
 
Tormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond reputeTormod has a reputation beyond repute
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
RE: Is space something or nothing?

Warm welcomes, geetee-w.

Which two "things" or "worlds" are you talking about?

If I have an apple and a banana and do not define a relationship between them, does that mean they must be either adjacent or overlapping?

I guess not - so I must be missing the point. But I guess there is a meaning to the term "pre-existing". Are you suggesting that spacetime was created for a purpose?


----------------
Your Friendly Neighborhood Administrator

Want to lose the advertisements? Become a Sponsor!

Join our Facebook group or follow us on Twitter

Science is not only compatible with spirituality; it is a profound source of spirituality.
- Carl Sagan
Old 09-10-2004   #3 (permalink)
Freethinker's Avatar
Resident Atheist


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Is space something or nothing?

Hi GToW. Glad to have new voices.
Quote:
Originally posted by: geeteenodubya
One can derive a solution for the properties of "empty space," but does it make sense?
Not quite sure what you are specifically referring to as "empty space,". The fluctuating quantum vacuum? intervals between dimensional manifolds?
Quote:
Is there any reason to assume a geometry must exist --
Only if we don't want to argue to absurdity. We could start with the assumption that nothing actually exists and go from there.
Quote:
that there cannot be two entirely unrelated things or worlds?
I am not aware of any such limitation. In fact in multi-verse two is a small number!
Quote:
If there is no pre-existing relationship defined by some geometry, then two things must either be adjacent or overlapping throughout their existence if they are to interact causally at any point.
Or a non-destructive boolean "and" which does not have to exist across the entirety of both timespaces'.
Quote:
It seems to me that quantum mechanics has shown that the contents of our spacetime might define our spacetime itself, not just its shape and metric.
Yes, and?


----------------
Thanks for helping to get god pounded into my head



Another succesful faith based initiative. Just like 9/11
Old 09-11-2004   #4 (permalink)
geeteenodubya's Avatar
Curious


 
geeteenodubya is an unknown quantity at this point
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Is space something or nothing?

"Empty space" typically means -- if I understand correctly -- a submanifold without content. It is a valid mathematical concept, but I'm curious whether it is part of reality. In particular, is it obvious that a region of "empty space" might be embedded within our spacetime metric?

My interpretation of a "relationship" between two things was geometrical. They are related if there is a path from one to the other. I think that is equivalent to saying they might be causally connected. I suppose there are comparisons that could be made between things that are not related in this way.
Old 09-11-2004   #5 (permalink)
Freethinker's Avatar
Resident Atheist


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Is space something or nothing?

Quote:
Originally posted by: geeteenodubya
"Empty space" typically means -- if I understand correctly -- a submanifold without content. It is a valid mathematical concept,
I thought that might be what you meant, but never know till I ask.
Quote:
but I'm curious whether it is part of reality. In particular, is it obvious that a region of "empty space" might be embedded within our spacetime metric?
As to it's part of reality, I guess we are still trying to figure out if the math it is a valid concept in, is valid? What's in between the intersections of at which other dimensions fold in on themselves? Untill we know whether this thought experiment preforms it doesn't matter? :-)

After we have developed a succesful TOE, we need a TON.
Quote:
My interpretation of a "relationship" between two things was geometrical. They are related if there is a path from one to the other. I think that is equivalent to saying they might be causally connected.
Yes semantices. Are you math oriented? It would seem rather than pilosophically oriented.


----------------
Thanks for helping to get god pounded into my head



Another succesful faith based initiative. Just like 9/11
Old 09-20-2004   #6 (permalink)
lindagarrette's Avatar
Explaining


Location:
Maryland Heights, MO
 
lindagarrette is a jewel in the roughlindagarrette is a jewel in the roughlindagarrette is a jewel in the rough
Send a message via ICQ to lindagarrette
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
RE: Is space something or nothing?

Trying to define space opens up a box of other issues. what is content? what is matter? Are they all just mathematical constructs? At the string theory level, for instance, there is no such thing as a particle. Also, at that level, there is no place in the universe that has no content. Or if there is, where is it. Only when there was nothing, like before the BB, was there no content. Right?


----------------
If god existed then science would be meaningless
Old 09-21-2004   #7 (permalink)
Freethinker's Avatar
Resident Atheist


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
RE: Is space something or nothing?

Quote:
Originally posted by: lindagarrette
Only when there was nothing, like before the BB, was there no content. Right?
This is where we have to be very careful. We can not say that there was nothing before the BB.

The BB is an event to which we can track back to what we understand to be the start of our current physical existence. "Before that?" may not be a valid question. Perhaps anything "thing" that existed before that would not follow what we understand as the laws of physics as they currently exist.


----------------
Thanks for helping to get god pounded into my head



Another succesful faith based initiative. Just like 9/11
Old 10-05-2004   #8 (permalink)
geeteenodubya's Avatar
Curious


 
geeteenodubya is an unknown quantity at this point
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Is space something or nothing?

I believe my question could be rephrased in terms of the "intervals between dimensional manifolds." However, my impression is that "interval" and "between" have no meaning in that context. The first question is whether the absence of a dimensional manifold is a meaningful concept, since no point can be located in it.

The second question is whether a real dimensional manifold can have no content. Would its shape be defined?
Old 11-26-2004   #9 (permalink)
paultrr's Avatar
Explaining


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
RE: Is space something or nothing?

Basically, everything we have as far as theory goes for the particle scale on down is a construct.
Old 12-04-2004   #10 (permalink)
DaDaLiCh's Avatar
Curious


 
DaDaLiCh is an unknown quantity at this point
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is space something or nothing?

There is only one thing which I need to state:

How could the the BB have happened, how could living being just spontaneosly be created or formed, even through evolution, without a divine being at the helm. I see this as impossible. God MUST have existed for the universe to be created with such precision. (Please excuse my english, it's my fourth language and i'm not very fluent yet)
Closed Thread

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Space in 2004 Stargazer Science News 3 08-13-2006 10:40 PM
More gravity... Eprom Physics and Mathematics 28 12-02-2004 03:07 AM
what is space? sanctus Physics and Mathematics 11 07-18-2004 02:21 PM
expansion of space through time =gravity? deamonstar Physics and Mathematics 1 07-31-2003 07:58 PM
Terraforming and cheap space launch Marcus Space 1 06-12-2003 06:56 AM

» Advertisement
» Current Poll
Who's the sexiest man alive? Johnny Depp or Robert Pattinson?
Johnny Depp - 30.00%
3 Votes
Robert Pattinson - 0%
0 Votes
Someone else (please specify) - 40.00%
4 Votes
I'm too macho to think a guy is sexy - 30.00%
3 Votes
Total Votes: 10
You may not vote on this poll.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:50 PM.

Hypography?

Hypography [n.]: A combination of "hyperlink" and "bibliography" - ie, a list of links to electronic documents. Comparable to discography and bibliography, but not cartography.

We have been online since May 2000, and aim to be the best place to find and share science-related content of all kinds.

Share the love!

Please add more science to your life. Use our RSS feeds on your blog, your portal, or your favorite feedreader!


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2
Copyright © 2000-2009 Hypography
Part of the Hypography - Science for Everyone Network