[pgrmdave]

From a Christian standpoint, is God good because He's God, or is goodness/evil above God?

[TINNY]

i'm afraid faiths and beliefs are not things we discuss here. Only logic and factual based topics.
what do you mean by goodness being above god?

[pgrmdave]

well, if God is the highest authority, than no matter what he did, it should be "good", whatever he had deemed to be good. But if there is an idea of "good" apart from God, then that must mean that God answers to a higher authority.

[sanctus]

Originally Posted by TINNY

i'm afraid faiths and beliefs are not things we discuss here. Only logic and factual based topics.

Well, you can speak about this topics on this forums as long as you don't expect people to believe as well in god and proofs that are none. Actually you should talk about it, as it can be very interesting. Even if I don't believe in an existence of any god I still can follow a logic discussion starting from an illogic argument (i.e. the existence of god).

Originally Posted by TINNY

what do you mean by goodness being above god?

I guess he simply wanted to say that if there is a "referential system" not made by god which says what is good or bad, then god isn't above everything.

[sanctus]

Originally Posted by pgrmdave

well, if God is the highest authority, than no matter what he did, it should be "good", whatever he had deemed to be good. But if there is an idea of "good" apart from God, then that must mean that God answers to a higher authority.

This just shows to me that the christian god is paradoxal from the start

[Tormod]

Originally Posted by TINNY

i'm afraid faiths and beliefs are not things we discuss here. Only logic and factual based topics.
what do you mean by goodness being above god?

Come on Tinny. You know that's not true!

[geko]

Originally Posted by pgrmdave

From a Christian standpoint, is God good because He's God, or is goodness/evil above God?

You've stated a classic there pgrmdave. Is good what god deems? Or is god good?

Good/bad, right/wrong could be argued as being subjective anyway. Personally, I see many myricals being done because man is good, not because im told they're good by man (or god).

Just my thoughts

[TINNY]

I guess he simply wanted to say that if there is a "referential system" not made by god which says what is good or bad, then god isn't above everything.

but then how can that fit in the definiiton of god?
In Islamic theology, goodness is action that aids progression towards perfection and evil is action that goes the opposite way. The manifestations of God is deemed goodneess.

[pgrmdave]

Originally Posted by TINNY

but then how can that fit in the definiiton of god?
In Islamic theology, goodness is action that aids progression towards perfection and evil is action that goes the opposite way. The manifestations of God is deemed goodneess.

That's a good question, what do we define as 'God'?

[pgrmdave]

I suppose that, for a simple definition, God is the conscious, guiding force of the universe