Go Back   Science Forums > General Science Forums > Philosophy Forums
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 08-18-2008   #1 (permalink)
dkv's Avatar
dkv
Questioning


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Is there any free will?

Respected Mathematicians have proved that it is not possible to have free will and determinism...
In other words either one has free will or is ruled by some deterministic algorithm.
News and Views: Do Subatomic particles have free will?


----------------
If facts dont fit the theory change the facts.
-A quote popularly attributed to Albert Einstein.
My Blog-http://storieswhichclicked.blogspot.com/
Reply With Quote
Old 08-18-2008   #2 (permalink)
Pyrotex's Avatar
Slaying Bad Memes

Moderator
Editor

Location:
Houston, Texas
Latest blog entry:
 
Pyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond reputePyrotex has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via MSN to Pyrotex
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

Quote:
Originally Posted by dkv View Post
Respected Mathematicians have proved that it is not possible to have free will and determinism... ...[/url]
Nonsense.
I repeat, Nonsense.

Math tricks and philosophical mumbo jumbo cannot PROVE anything about consciousness, let alone "free will".

What will it take to constitute a PROOF (either way)???
First, an unambiguous definition of "free will";
then a decisive experiment based on that definition, where a number of individuals are placed in a carefully crafted set of circumstances, such that IF the individuals select a certain option ALL the time, it proves they have NO free will -- OR, if the individuals select a certain option 50% of the time, it proves they DO have free will.

Until you can perform the experiment, all the jibber-jabber, fancy rhetoric, ivory-tower philosophy and math juggling in the world is a total waste of time.


----------------
Hypography Forums Moderator
-- - - - - -
What concerns me is not the way things are, but rather the way people think things are.
Epictetus, Greek Philosopher
The map is NOT the territory.
Korzybski, Polish-American Philosopher
Reply With Quote
Old 08-18-2008   #3 (permalink)
Nitack's Avatar
Understanding


Location:
Washington DC
 
Nitack has much to be proud ofNitack has much to be proud ofNitack has much to be proud ofNitack has much to be proud ofNitack has much to be proud ofNitack has much to be proud ofNitack has much to be proud of
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

In what context?

Free Will
Quote:
The principle of free will has religious, ethical, and scientific implications. For example, in the religious realm, free will may imply that an omnipotent divinity does not assert its power over individual will and choices. In ethics, it may imply that individuals can be held morally accountable for their actions. In the scientific realm, it may imply that the actions of the body, including the brain and the mind, are not wholly determined by physical causality. The question of free will has been a central issue since the beginning of philosophical thought.
Reply With Quote
Old 08-18-2008   #4 (permalink)
Thunderbird's Avatar
Creating


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

Quote:
The hypothesis in question is '...that "You", your joys and your sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of personal identity and free will, are in fact no more than the behaviour of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their associated molecules."
Francis Crick
-------------------------------------
The most profound story I’ve ever read comes one from one of Carlos Castaneda’s books, I can’t recall which one, but it was like many of his “tales of eternity” they always hint at more than they actually say .

This one starts with the old shaman Don Juan and his apprentice the anthropology student Carlos observing some desert creatures as they scurried about in the desert chaparral.

Don Juan commented that a man could survive in the dessert by hunting those animals, But first you would need to study them and know their habits.
He explain how they followed a pattern that could be mapped as a circle around a burrow. Once these feeding cycles are learned snares could be set and escape routes could be routed, so the animals own cyclical behavior became its venerability.
But he warned his apprentice, as you follow these behaviors and set your snares every day in the same way, you also make yourself venerable because you too are being observed.
He said there were predators even more attuned to theses circular patterns of the dessert, so some day something could be waiting for you along one of your well worn paths.

He went on to say that there existed in nature an ultimate balance between awareness of these cyclical movements in the world and a spontaneity of action in ones self, an unpredictability that wells up from the spirit.
Once this balance is achieved the hunter becomes a “magical warrior.”
“A magical warrior can never be trapped” don Juan said or “be caught without an escape route,” because he can never be reduced to behaviors .

This “warrior’s path” are no longer connected to cycles of the world, but of the spirit, thus he can always “see” what is coming without being seen himself.

Also, he said there existed in the world animals “magical creatures.” that have achieved this balance.

Don Juan recounted that he himself had achieved this state as a young man and became a magical warrior, and seemed to always know instinctively what to do in any situation, until one day he was hunting on a heavily forested ridge top. He remembered hearing a strange sound that sent shivers though his body.

He knew instinctively that he was to about to have an encounter with a magical creature, and for the first time since he had reached this state he had no clue what to do.

So he did the most illogical thing. He stood on his head and began to cry, after some time he felt something breathing in his ear, he fell over in a sitting position and looked up at the most beautiful deer that he had ever seen, and then it spoke “ Why are you crying ?” the deer inquired “ Because I'm sad ” Don Juan heard himself reply, then he remembered the deer lowered his head and said very clearly “ Don’t be sad ” and ambled away.

After listening to Don Juan’s story, Carlos, being an anthropologist and a man of logic and science, replied that the story was ridicules “deer’s do not talk !” he said “I know I know” the old shaman replied “It was the damndest thing.”


----------------

I do not know what I seem to the world, but to myself I appear to have been like a boy playing upon the seashore and diverting myself by now and then finding a smoother pebble or prettier shell than ordinary, while the great ocean of truth lay before me all undiscovered. - Sir Isaac Newton

Last edited by Thunderbird; 08-18-2008 at 08:06 AM..
Reply With Quote
Old 08-19-2008   #5 (permalink)
HydrogenBond's Avatar
Creating


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

I define free will as the ability to freely chose between subjective alternatives, without a bias, that slants you one way. If there is an apple and orange on the table free will is happy with either. When it comes to objectivity, free will, will chose the objective path because it is not compelled by subjectivity, which would amount to an irrational bias.

There are also situations where there are many logical explanations. Free will will not chose one, but can freely move between logical alternatives. In this case, the subjective bias is hidden in social subjective factors such as fad, prestige, biggest herd, etc.
Reply With Quote
Old 08-19-2008   #6 (permalink)
C1ay's Avatar
¿42?

Administrator
Senior Editor
Editor

Location:
33.78N 84.66W
 
C1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond repute
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

Quote:
Originally Posted by dkv View Post
Respected Mathematicians have proved that it is not possible to have free will and determinism...
Define free will.


----------------
Clay

Editor and Forum Administrator
stego anyone?
Add yourself to Hypography's Frappr.
"There are only 10 kinds of people in the world --
.....Those who understand binary, and those who don't."
"Draw no conclusions before their time."
Reply With Quote
Old 08-19-2008   #7 (permalink)
Zythryn's Avatar
Creating

Platinum Subscription
Sponsor

Location:
Minnesota
 
Zythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond reputeZythryn has a reputation beyond repute
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

Quote:
Originally Posted by HydrogenBond View Post
I define free will as the ability to freely chose between subjective alternatives, without a bias, that slants you one way. If there is an apple and orange on the table free will is happy with either. When it comes to objectivity, free will, will chose the objective path because it is not compelled by subjectivity, which would amount to an irrational bias.
I would define free will as the ability to chose one alternative even though your bias is to choose the other


----------------
"Treat the earth well: it was not given to you by your parents; it was loaned to you by your children. We do not inherit the earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children.

(Ancient Indian Proverb)"

1874 engraving of Mount Hood and the Columbia River by R. Henshel Wood
Reply With Quote
Old 08-19-2008   #8 (permalink)
C1ay's Avatar
¿42?

Administrator
Senior Editor
Editor

Location:
33.78N 84.66W
 
C1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond reputeC1ay has a reputation beyond repute
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

Quote:
Originally Posted by HydrogenBond View Post
I define free will as the ability to freely chose between subjective alternatives, without a bias....
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zythryn View Post
I would define free will as the ability to chose one alternative even though your bias is to choose the other
Define bias. Are either of you referring to a simple apparent urge or tendency or an underlying chemical action taking place in the brain's electro-chemical computing unit that may or may not be casual to bias? What exactly is bias and is it necessarily a consciously perceptible part of the cognitive process?


----------------
Clay

Editor and Forum Administrator
stego anyone?
Add yourself to Hypography's Frappr.
"There are only 10 kinds of people in the world --
.....Those who understand binary, and those who don't."
"Draw no conclusions before their time."
Reply With Quote
Old 08-19-2008   #9 (permalink)
Thunderbird's Avatar
Creating


 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pyrotex View Post
Nonsense.
I repeat, Nonsense.

Math tricks and philosophical mumbo jumbo cannot PROVE anything about consciousness, let alone "free will".

What will it take to constitute a PROOF (either way)???
First, an unambiguous definition of "free will";
then a decisive experiment based on that definition, where a number of individuals are placed in a carefully crafted set of circumstances, such that IF the individuals select a certain option ALL the time, it proves they have NO free will -- OR, if the individuals select a certain option 50% of the time, it proves they DO have free will.

Until you can perform the experiment, all the jibber-jabber, fancy rhetoric, ivory-tower philosophy and math juggling in the world is a total waste of time.
It may be hard to define free will.... but it sure is easy to see it in people. Some people are more prototypes, they repeat what they see or is said. Being around them for time you can usually predict what they will do, or say in a given situation. They have become a slave to a program that has lost its fluidity . Others, much fewer are archetypes they responses to situations though spontaneity, fluidity, instinctively, creatively and humor constantly updating their internal program to adapt to a new set of challenges.


----------------

I do not know what I seem to the world, but to myself I appear to have been like a boy playing upon the seashore and diverting myself by now and then finding a smoother pebble or prettier shell than ordinary, while the great ocean of truth lay before me all undiscovered. - Sir Isaac Newton
Reply With Quote
Old 08-19-2008   #10 (permalink)
Galapagos's Avatar
Explaining

Basic Subscription
Sponsor

Location:
Fl
 
Galapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond reputeGalapagos has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to Galapagos
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: Is there any free will?

I don't think that free will in the sense that we can become whatever we choose, do whatever we'd like with ourselves etc. exists. I can't place in the Olympics, write anything like Shakespeare, or make any number of decisions(or post replies) that do not occur to me right now, because my mind is limited by the (currently incomprehensibly complex) physical interactions in my brain.
I can however choose from a list of possible actions so vast that no human being(including myself) could ever predict my actions in a reliable manner, so I have about as much free will as I could ever want anyway.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Free from the Atmosphere C1ay Science News 1 06-13-2007 06:17 PM
My Best Argument Against Free Will Tarantism Philosophy Forums 25 09-10-2006 10:16 AM
Free Will Tarantism Philosophy of Science 44 06-20-2006 08:48 AM
Do you believe in free will? bumab Philosophy Forums 44 03-25-2005 07:37 AM

» Advertisement
» Current Poll
Who's the sexiest man alive? Johnny Depp or Robert Pattinson?
Johnny Depp - 27.27%
3 Votes
Robert Pattinson - 0%
0 Votes
Someone else (please specify) - 45.45%
5 Votes
I'm too macho to think a guy is sexy - 27.27%
3 Votes
Total Votes: 11
You may not vote on this poll.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:08 PM.

Hypography?

Hypography [n.]: A combination of "hyperlink" and "bibliography" - ie, a list of links to electronic documents. Comparable to discography and bibliography, but not cartography.

We have been online since May 2000, and aim to be the best place to find and share science-related content of all kinds.

Share the love!

Please add more science to your life. Use our RSS feeds on your blog, your portal, or your favorite feedreader!


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2
Copyright © 2000-2009 Hypography
Part of the Hypography - Science for Everyone Network