Go Back   Science Forums > General Science Forums > Philosophy Forums > Philosophy of Science
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 07-08-2009   #161 (permalink)
Larv's Avatar
Understanding


Location:
just south of Canuckistan
 
Larv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to behold
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rade View Post
Well, the spider species discussed below has behavior that suggests it may well be doing some of the things on your list....

Dichotomistic logic - do spiders have a mind
Metaphors can be mighty intoxicating, as in (from your link): "Luckily Portia has brains. In fact it is the veritable Einstein of the arthropod world." But I seriously doubt that little Portia qualifies as being either a scientist or an engineer.

Quote:
Keep in mind, there are only two ways to 'know' anything: (1) from inside the thing, (2) from outside the thing.
I didn't know that.

Quote:
Do not assume that you "know" anything that goes on inside the brain of the spider, you know only what the spider allows you to know from observation of its behavior.
Then I'm confused about how you know that spiders are scientists and engineers.

Quote:
Science is not a list of activities done or a method of such activities, science is the process of having "uncertain knowledge" of that which exists. Spiders show all the behaviors of having such knowledge of their surroundings.
I think it's OK to say, by way of metaphor, that spiders seem to "know" things and do "science" and "engineering." But it's important to remember that humans have a knack for anthropomorphizing and resorting to teleology when trying to explain animal behavior. Indeed science is in the business of filtering out such nonsense.


----------------
The most incomprehensible thing about nature is that it is comprehensible. —Albert The Einstein
Reply With Quote
Old 07-09-2009   #162 (permalink)
SidewalkCynic's Avatar
Thinking


Location:
NYC
 
SidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these parts
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

Please ..., what description does science use for explaining why a spider does what it does?

"Instinct"???
Reply With Quote
Old 07-09-2009   #163 (permalink)
Larv's Avatar
Understanding


Location:
just south of Canuckistan
 
Larv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to behold
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

Quote:
Originally Posted by SidewalkCynic View Post
Please ..., what description does science use for explaining why a spider does what it does?

"Instinct"???
I've already addressed this in post #156


----------------
The most incomprehensible thing about nature is that it is comprehensible. —Albert The Einstein
Reply With Quote
Old 07-09-2009   #164 (permalink)
SidewalkCynic's Avatar
Thinking


Location:
NYC
 
SidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these parts
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

All you provided was an argument that a spider does not practice science.

I want to know what science describes as the animating force of the spider to do what it does?
Reply With Quote
Old 07-09-2009   #165 (permalink)
Larv's Avatar
Understanding


Location:
just south of Canuckistan
 
Larv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to behold
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

Quote:
Originally Posted by SidewalkCynic View Post
All you provided was an argument that a spider does not practice science.

I want to know what science describes as the animating force of the spider to do what it does?
Science knows of no such "animating force." And Occam's Razor shaved off that whisker called "elan vital" long ago.


----------------
The most incomprehensible thing about nature is that it is comprehensible. —Albert The Einstein
Reply With Quote
Old 07-10-2009   #166 (permalink)
enorbet2's Avatar
Understanding


Location:
Does anal retentive require a hyphen, or only a semi-colon?
 
enorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond reputeenorbet2 has a reputation beyond repute
Send a message via AIM to enorbet2
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

AFAIK Science has yet to provide a good description or even a good evolutionary reason for consciousness, in that it disappears when we sleep and is nearly instantly re-manufactured complete with an intact and coherent personality, a binding thread, if you will, upon awaking. Please don't get me wrong I am not seeing this as any kind of failure on the part of Science but rather some shared by the provincial conceit of being human ("What a piece of work is man, how noble in reason, how infinite in faculties, in form and moving- how express and admirable, in action - how like an angel, in apprehension how like a god!" - Hamlet via Willy) and lack of the appropriate technology. It disturbs me some how we write off so-called lower creatures, especially Porpoises and Whales, as possessing only instinct when they can have more neural connections per volume, more brain mass, etc etc. It pleases me somehow that our very description of Life has had to be altered by so-called "extremophiles".

In any case, regarding spiders weaving webs, I wonder how our definition of instinct applies when the manner in which they build webs can be so similarly affected by administering psychoactive drugs. Here are some informative links and one really fun interactive video.

Spiders On Drugs

Effects Of Drugs And Alcohol On Spider Webs • VideoSift: Online Video *Quality Control

Spiders On Drugs

It pleases me most that imaginative scientists have begun to actively imagine how other lifeforms may exist even among the higher clouds of Jupiter, or in the methane seas of Titan. I sincerely hope that life is discovered on Mars soon, and especially if it is not DNA based (or even carbon based) that 1) we recognize it as life, and 2) we get the implication that Life is essentially ubiquitous, something that chemistry just tends to do over a sufficient length of time.
Reply With Quote
Old 07-10-2009   #167 (permalink)
modest's Avatar
Creating

Moderator

Location:
U.S. Midwest
 
modest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond repute
 



Neutral  +1 score     
Re: What is Science?

Quote:
Originally Posted by SidewalkCynic View Post
I want to know what science describes as the animating force of the spider to do what it does?
I'm not entirely sure what this sentence means. Nonetheless,

The forces which animate a spider are no different from the fundamental forces of physics. Not long ago (mid-19th century) scientists believed that living matter was different from non-living matter in that it had protoplasm which was capable of its own impetus. Many believed that life was a property of this protoplasm.

Pharmaceutical journal: A weekly ... - Google Books

It is now more widely held that life is an emergent property of matter—needing no special impetus or force of animation beyond the normal laws of chemistry and physics (Materialism).

The study of how and why animals move is called biomechanics. To specifically study insects or to explain an insect with science is called entomology which is a field of zoology which is a branch of biology.

~modest


----------------
Reply With Quote
Old 07-11-2009   #168 (permalink)
Larv's Avatar
Understanding


Location:
just south of Canuckistan
 
Larv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to beholdLarv is a splendid one to behold
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

Quote:
Originally Posted by modest View Post
I'm not entirely sure what this sentence means. Nonetheless,

The forces which animate a spider are no different from the fundamental forces of physics. Not long ago (mid-19th century) scientists believed that living matter was different from non-living matter in that it had protoplasm which was capable of its own impetus. Many believed that life was a property of this protoplasm.

Pharmaceutical journal: A weekly ... - Google Books

It is now more widely held that life is an emergent property of matter—needing no special impetus or force of animation beyond the normal laws of chemistry and physics (Materialism).

The study of how and why animals move is called biomechanics. To specifically study insects or to explain an insect with science is called entomology which is a field of zoology which is a branch of biology.

~modest
A much better response than mine. Mine was flapjack; yours is educational. As a biologist, though, I still struggle with understanding this allegedly emergent property called life. Am I to understand it as something like the emergent property of, say, liquid water from the oxidation of hydrogen? I think declaring something an emergent property is a bit of a cop out. It's like using another word for magic. And there, precisely, may be where the metaphysicians gain a foothold.

Do you think science alone is adequate for explaining life? I think it has to be, but we seem a long way from explaining it in any meaningful way that enables us to make it from scratch in the laboratory. And I think there are some HUGE principles we haven't yet discovered.


----------------
The most incomprehensible thing about nature is that it is comprehensible. —Albert The Einstein
Reply With Quote
Old 07-11-2009   #169 (permalink)
SidewalkCynic's Avatar
Thinking


Location:
NYC
 
SidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these partsSidewalkCynic is infamous around these parts
 



Not Ranked  0 score     
Re: What is Science?

Quote:
Originally Posted by modest View Post
I'm not entirely sure what this sentence means. Nonetheless,
I think you describe what I am looking for here...
Quote:
Originally Posted by modest View Post
The study of how and why animals move is called biomechanics. To specifically study insects or to explain an insect with science is called entomology which is a field of zoology which is a branch of biology.

~modest
I'm looking forward to reviewing this and a couple of other subjects I have been directed to in this and other threads, so my dance card is full, right now, and I am trying to go over it all, and keep up with my project, as well. Thanks.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Unusual science or less than main stream science. Moontanman Watercooler 1 09-05-2008 02:24 AM
Normal Science is Lamp-Post Science coberst Philosophy Forums 6 08-14-2008 05:28 AM
Philosophy of Science: Science is About Solving Puzzles coberst Philosophy Forums 5 06-08-2006 07:06 AM
This Week in Science - online science radio program Marshall Clark Websites 2 07-23-2005 08:44 AM
Current Science Fiction = Future Science Fact? Noah Computer Science and Technology 18 06-09-2004 02:14 PM

» Advertisement
» Current Poll
Who's the sexiest man alive? Johnny Depp or Robert Pattinson?
Johnny Depp - 30.00%
3 Votes
Robert Pattinson - 0%
0 Votes
Someone else (please specify) - 40.00%
4 Votes
I'm too macho to think a guy is sexy - 30.00%
3 Votes
Total Votes: 10
You may not vote on this poll.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:57 PM.

Hypography?

Hypography [n.]: A combination of "hyperlink" and "bibliography" - ie, a list of links to electronic documents. Comparable to discography and bibliography, but not cartography.

We have been online since May 2000, and aim to be the best place to find and share science-related content of all kinds.

Share the love!

Please add more science to your life. Use our RSS feeds on your blog, your portal, or your favorite feedreader!


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2
Copyright © 2000-2009 Hypography
Part of the Hypography - Science for Everyone Network