Physics and Mathematics Formulae, ideas, theories, speed of light, black holes...


Advertisement (please log in or register to remove this ad)
Notices

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 01-25-2008, 05:46 AM
sanctus's Avatar
Resident Diabolist
Points: 29,076, Level: 74 Points: 29,076, Level: 74 Points: 29,076, Level: 74
Activity: 4% Activity: 4% Activity: 4%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
 

Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Geneva-Bern-Zürich, Switzerland
Posts: 2,449
Blog Entries: 1
sanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to all
Very mean squareroot!

Have you already noticed that
\sqrt{-x}\cdot\sqrt{-y}=\pm\sqrt{xy}

Thing is that for half an hour I searched which of the two reasoponings is wrong:

1)
\sqrt{-x}\cdot\sqrt{-y}=\sqrt{(-1)\cdot x \cdot(-1)\cdot y}= \sqrt{xy}
Since -1*-1=+1

2)
\sqrt{-x}\cdot\sqrt{-y}= i\cdot\sqrt{x}\cdot i\cdot\sqrt{y}=i^2\sqrt{xy}=-\sqrt{xy}
Since i^2=-1

It took me as already said more than 3 min to figure it out, hope to you it isn't obvious at first read why both versions are right (and incomplete)...just so that I don't feel too stupid
__________________
Administrator

A COUNTRY WITHOUT AN ARMY IS LIKE A FISH WITHOUT A BIKE!!!


I don't believe in god, but I do believe in what others call utopies.

Last edited by sanctus; 01-28-2008 at 10:37 PM.
Reply With Quote
Advertisement
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 01-25-2008, 07:16 AM
Qfwfq's Avatar
Exhausted Gondolier
Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88
Activity: 2% Activity: 2% Activity: 2%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
 

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: the fringes of the lagoon
Posts: 4,316
Qfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to behold
Lightbulb Re: Very mean squareroot!

I'm just replying on the fly but I'd say it's a matter of considering both roots of a number vs. only considering the principal root (of a positive real).
__________________
The velocity of light in vacuo is c, but c isn't just the velocity of light.

Inutil insegnŕ al mus, si piart timp, in plui si infastiděs la bestie.

Everything that ever was is a song that is sung into existence.
orbsycli.

Hypography Forum PITA...... er, Moderator.
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 01-25-2008, 08:30 AM
freeztar's Avatar
In the Spatula Zone
Points: 122,810, Level: 100 Points: 122,810, Level: 100 Points: 122,810, Level: 100
Activity: 100% Activity: 100% Activity: 100%
Hypography Staff Member
Moderator
Editor
 
3 Reel Flash Slots Champion! 1992 Champion! 30k Starfighter Champion!
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: ATL, GA, USA
Posts: 5,064
Blog Entries: 4
freeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Very mean squareroot!

That is a good question. I'd be more inclined to go with the second scenario you presented.
__________________
Hypography Science Forums Moderator
---
"There are no passengers on Spaceship Earth. We are all crew." - Marshall McLuhan

"We must not forget that when radium was discovered no one knew that it would prove useful in hospitals. The work was one of pure science. And this is a proof that scientific work must not be considered from the point of view of the direct usefulness of it." - Marie Curie
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 01-26-2008, 12:45 AM
Qfwfq's Avatar
Exhausted Gondolier
Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88
Activity: 2% Activity: 2% Activity: 2%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
 

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: the fringes of the lagoon
Posts: 4,316
Qfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to behold
Lightbulb Re: Very mean squareroot!

Quote:
Originally Posted by freeztar View Post
I'd be more inclined to go with the second scenario...
I'd be more inclined to confirm my on-the-fly reply.

What is the square root of a^2? Think carefully of what "square root" actually means.

a^2=a\cdot a=-a\cdot -a=(-1)a\cdot(-1)a=(-1)(-1)a\cdot a=(+1)a\cdot a

Try taking "the" square root of each one and pondering it over.

a^4=a\cdot a\cdot a\cdot a=(-1)a\cdot(-1)a\cdot(-1)a\cdot(-1)a=a\cdot a\cdot(-1)a\cdot(-1)a.....
__________________
The velocity of light in vacuo is c, but c isn't just the velocity of light.

Inutil insegnŕ al mus, si piart timp, in plui si infastiděs la bestie.

Everything that ever was is a song that is sung into existence.
orbsycli.

Hypography Forum PITA...... er, Moderator.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 01-26-2008, 01:14 AM
freeztar's Avatar
In the Spatula Zone
Points: 122,810, Level: 100 Points: 122,810, Level: 100 Points: 122,810, Level: 100
Activity: 100% Activity: 100% Activity: 100%
Hypography Staff Member
Moderator
Editor
 
3 Reel Flash Slots Champion! 1992 Champion! 30k Starfighter Champion!
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: ATL, GA, USA
Posts: 5,064
Blog Entries: 4
freeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond reputefreeztar has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Very mean squareroot!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Qfwfq View Post
a^4=a cdot a cdot a cdot a=(-1)a cdot(-1)a cdot(-1)a cdot(-1)a=a cdot a cdot(-1)a cdot(-1)a.....
I see your point.


(what's up with the quoted [math]?)
__________________
Hypography Science Forums Moderator
---
"There are no passengers on Spaceship Earth. We are all crew." - Marshall McLuhan

"We must not forget that when radium was discovered no one knew that it would prove useful in hospitals. The work was one of pure science. And this is a proof that scientific work must not be considered from the point of view of the direct usefulness of it." - Marie Curie

Last edited by freeztar; 01-26-2008 at 01:20 AM. Reason: latex issue
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 01-26-2008, 02:56 AM
modest's Avatar
Creating
Points: 84,851, Level: 100 Points: 84,851, Level: 100 Points: 84,851, Level: 100
Activity: 100% Activity: 100% Activity: 100%
Hypography Staff Member
Moderator
 

Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: U.S. Midwest
Posts: 1,690
modest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond reputemodest has a reputation beyond repute
Re: Very mean squareroot!

Quote:
Originally Posted by freeztar View Post

(what's up with the quoted [math]?)
I've noticed that as well, it strips the backslashes. We would have to ask Alex what's up.

-modest

PS - I think latex is handled beautifully on hypography and I realize how much work would have to go into that.
__________________

Last edited by modest; 01-26-2008 at 03:01 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 01-26-2008, 09:17 AM
Creating
Points: 120,481, Level: 100 Points: 120,481, Level: 100 Points: 120,481, Level: 100
Activity: 42% Activity: 42% Activity: 42%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
Editor
 

Join Date: May 2005
Location: Silver Spring, MD, USA
Posts: 4,319
CraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond reputeCraigD has a reputation beyond repute
Post Arithmatic expression vs. set description connotation of the square root

I think we’ve had essentially this same discussion before.

The root of the dilemma, I think, is that the square root glyph can be interpreted several ways.

\sqrt{x} can be considered simple equivalent to x^{\frac12}, e^{\frac12 \ln x}, or various infinite series expressions, in which case its sign is positive.

Or, \sqrt{x} can be considered the description of a set, \{ a : x = a \cdot a \}, which is equivalent to \{ -\sqrt{x}, \sqrt{x} \}.

As long as writer and reader are aware of which connotation is appropriate for the use to which the glyph is being put, there should be no problem.
__________________
Moderator: Computers and Technology; Medical Science; Science Projects and Homework; Philosophy of Science; Physics and Mathematics; Environmental Studies
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
Old 01-28-2008, 03:09 AM
Qfwfq's Avatar
Exhausted Gondolier
Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88
Activity: 2% Activity: 2% Activity: 2%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
 

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: the fringes of the lagoon
Posts: 4,316
Qfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to behold
Re: Arithmatic expression vs. set description connotation of the square root

Quote:
Originally Posted by CraigD View Post
sqrt{x} can be considered simple equivalent to x^{frac12}, e^{frac12 ln x}, or various infinite series expressions, in which case its sign is positive.
(ab)^{\frac12}=(a)^{\frac12}(b)^{\frac12}=(-a\cdot-b)^{\frac12}=(-a)^{\frac12}(-b)^{\frac12}



A square root of \alpha is a root of the equation z^2=\alpha.
__________________
The velocity of light in vacuo is c, but c isn't just the velocity of light.

Inutil insegnŕ al mus, si piart timp, in plui si infastiděs la bestie.

Everything that ever was is a song that is sung into existence.
orbsycli.

Hypography Forum PITA...... er, Moderator.
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 01-28-2008, 10:39 PM
sanctus's Avatar
Resident Diabolist
Points: 29,076, Level: 74 Points: 29,076, Level: 74 Points: 29,076, Level: 74
Activity: 4% Activity: 4% Activity: 4%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
 

Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Geneva-Bern-Zürich, Switzerland
Posts: 2,449
Blog Entries: 1
sanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to allsanctus is a name known to all
Re: Arithmatic expression vs. set description connotation of the square root

First of all it took me 30min and not 3min to figure it out.
Second I agree with you, the way I saw it is:
1)
\sqrt{-x}\cdot\sqrt{-y}=\sqrt{(-1)\cdot x \cdot(-1)\cdot y}= \sqrt{1}\cdot\sqrt{xy}=\pm \sqrt{xy} since \sqrt{1}=\pm 1

2)
\sqrt{-x}\cdot\sqrt{-y}= \pm i\cdot\sqrt{x}\cdot \pm i\cdot\sqrt{y}=\mp i^2\sqrt{xy}=\pm\sqrt{xy}
Since \sqrt{-1}=\pm i, but this is strange as it implies that the definition of the imaginary unit is not unique.
__________________
Administrator

A COUNTRY WITHOUT AN ARMY IS LIKE A FISH WITHOUT A BIKE!!!


I don't believe in god, but I do believe in what others call utopies.
Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)  
Old 01-29-2008, 12:23 AM
Qfwfq's Avatar
Exhausted Gondolier
Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88 Points: 40,311, Level: 88
Activity: 2% Activity: 2% Activity: 2%
Hypography Staff Member
Administrator
 

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: the fringes of the lagoon
Posts: 4,316
Qfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to beholdQfwfq is a splendid one to behold
Re: Arithmatic expression vs. set description connotation of the square root

Quote:
Originally Posted by sanctus View Post
it implies that the definition of the imaginary unit is not unique.
Well, that doesn't really matter, does it?
__________________
The velocity of light in vacuo is c, but c isn't just the velocity of light.

Inutil insegnŕ al mus, si piart timp, in plui si infastiděs la bestie.

Everything that ever was is a song that is sung into existence.
orbsycli.

Hypography Forum PITA...... er, Moderator.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks
Advertisement


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

» Advertisement
» Latest Science News
A Fine-Tooth Comb To Measure The Accelerating Universe
imageAstronomical instruments needed to answer crucial questions, such as the search for Earth-like planets or the way the Universe expands, have come a step closer with the first demonstration at the telescope of a new calibration system for precise spectrographs. The method uses a Nobel Prize-winning technology called a 'laser frequency comb', and is published in this week's issue of Science.
Read » | 0 comments

Fermilab physicists discover "doubly strange" particle
imagePhysicists of the DZero experiment at the U.S. Department of Energy's Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory have discovered a new particle made of three quarks, the Omega-sub-b (Ωb). The particle contains two strange quarks and a bottom quark (s-s-b). It is an exotic relative of the much more common proton and weighs about six times the proton mass.
Read » | 0 comments

Stanford's 'autonomous' helicopters teach themselves to fly
imageStanford computer scientists have developed an artificial intelligence system that enables robotic helicopters to teach themselves to fly difficult stunts by watching other helicopters perform the same maneuvers. The result is an autonomous helicopter than can perform a complete airshow of complex tricks on its own.
Read » | 0 comments
» Current Poll
Do U text?
No - 37.14%
13 Votes
Yes; < 6 messages/day - 40.00%
14 Votes
Yes; 6-15 messages/day - 11.43%
4 Votes
Yes; 16 to 43 messages/day - 5.71%
2 Votes
Yes; > 43 messages/day - 2.86%
1 Vote
What? - 2.86%
1 Vote
Total Votes: 35
You may not vote on this poll.
» Random Social Groups
Guitarists
4 members | 0 pictures
ESP
5 members | 10 pictures
WHO BELIEVES IN UFO?
4 members | 28 pictures
The Prophesy: Crew Members
6 members | 0 pictures
Hypography jugglers
5 members | 7 pictures
» View All Groups
Advertisement

All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:32 PM.