It is a misconception that a republic is not a democracy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nitack
If you pulled aside almost any person on the street and asked them if the US form of government was a democracy they would say that it is, which is not true. the US is a republic.
|
On which street?
I know the misconception is radicated in the US; the link TB provided only shows
why the different perspective developed there. It does not prove the case as being so throughout the world (or even only just in the English Language of other countries) and it is even slightly self-contradictory in discussing some examples. It's also a misconception that the meanings have to do with guarantees such as principle of precedent, separation of powers, constitution etc.
In most western languages, correspondents of both terms are present despite them being derived from the Greek and the Latin words for essentially the same thing (not a monarchy or tyranny). The Latin one (
respublica, a contraction of
rex publica populi romani and meaning affair of the people) came to have a more specific meaning, although not usually the one claimed in TB's link, than δημοκρατία
coined from δήμος and κράτος. This difference is largely due to the fact the the small and independent Greek πολις (in each of which the ruling class wasn't too large) it was feasible to decide everything in assemblies whereas the larger and expanding
Respublica Romana called for a representative democracy of increasing complexity with substantially more guarantees, which culminated with re-institution of the
senate.
This makes the difference in usage in most countries understandable but doesn't imply a replublic not being a democracy, or any of what is in TB's link. It is noteworthy that many countries are considered modern democracies because they have elective parliaments and ample guarantees but are not called republics because the head of state is not an elective office. The word
republic is typically understood as not a monarchy, while democracy means either this or at least not an absolute one. It is also noteworthy that modern Greek never adopted a derivation of the Latin term, it uses δημοκρατία in both ways.
----------------
Inutil insegnŕ al mus, si piart timp, in plui si infastiděs la bestie.
Hypography Forum PITA...... er, Administrator.
